Have you lost your entrepreneurs relief?

Now the dust has settled on the initial budget announcements, the details of the new legislation are emerging.

One significant change for business owners are the new rules on Entrepreneurs Relief (ER).

Background

Up to the day of the 2018 Autumn Budget (29/10/18) the following conditions had to be met to qualify for ER

  • The company must be a trading company or the holding company of a trading group.
  • The shareholder must be an officer or employee of the company for 12 months.
  • The shareholder must hold 5% of the nominal share capital for a period no less than 12 months.
  • The shareholder must hold 5% of voting rights for a period no less than 12 months.

By manipulating the rights attached to the shares it was possible to obtain the benefit of ER without any real capital risk. In order to counteract this the Chancellor announced two new conditions to the four listed above, effective immediately:

  • Shareholders must be entitled to at least 5% of the company’s distributable profits.
  • Shareholders must have a right to at least 5% of the net assets of the company available to equity holders on a winding-up.

The Chancellor also extended the continuous holding period from 12 month to 24 months.

That seems quite straightforward, so what’s the issue?

Individuals who have one class of shares and whose articles state they rank ‘pari passu’ on a distribution and a winding up, will not be affected as it can be demonstrated that they have a right to at least a 5% of the capital on a winding up and at least 5% of any distributable profits.

But what about individuals with Alphabet shares?  How confident can a shareholder be that they are entitled to 5% of the company’s distributable reserves when in fact one shareholder could receive 100% of the distribution by virtue of the provisions in the Articles?

Also, what about growth shares where a ratchet exists which pays out others a fixed amount, on a winding up without specific reference these individuals are not ‘entitled’ to at least 5% on a winding up.

In fact, we believe that ER is at risk in all the following circumstances:

  • Growth shares (where the shares benefit only on a proportion of an uplift in value)
  • Low or nil dividend paying shares
  • Ratchet share structures (where capital is received after a ring-fenced amount)
  • Shares with different nominal values
  • Convertible securities, preference shares and certain financing arrangements with shareholder loans

Shareholder or investment agreements referring to restrictions on voting or dividend rights

In the above scenarios the tax rate for the individual post 28th October just doubled.

It is not believed that this was an intended effect but without further clarification from HMRC a significant number of individuals will have just lost the ability to claim ER and with a 2-year qualifying period, those directors intending to sell will need to amend their articles and hold the shares for a 2-year period before the tax rate reverts to 10%

Next Steps

The government were effusive in their belief for ER and the benefits that it brings, so we’re hoping that they will offer more clarification on the situation.  If clarification is not forthcoming however individuals may need to review their Articles and Shareholders Agreements and amend them to get the qualifying period for ER started again


This article is for general guidance only. It provides an outline, and may not include points which are important to your situation. You should not depend on this blog without taking advice based on the full facts of your case. The information given was correct at the time of publication.

DID YOU FIND THIS USEFUL?

Share it with your network:  

Want more great content?
Sign up to our newsletter

Follow us

Tweets by @CHW-accounting

CHW-Accounting
@chw-accounting


Twitter: chw_accounting

WHAT'S THE NEWS?

Grab a biscuit and a brew and read our latest news.

10 December 2018

Making Tax Digital – What are your software options?

by

The biggest question many businesses have regarding Making Tax Digital is “Will my existing software work or do I need to upgrade / buy something else?”


Read more >

23 November 2018

Are HMRC Interest Charges Unfair?

by

MRC have been accused of being ‘grossly unfair’ when it comes to the interest it charges on money it is owed compared to interest it pays on refunds due.


Read more >

20 November 2018

2016-17 HMRC Exclusion Errors

by

HMRC have confirmed that from 19 November 2018 they will be reviewing and reworking up to 30,000 self-assessment returns for the tax year 2016/17 which were…


Read more >

19 November 2018

Why might HMRC investigate my business?

by

Nicola Roby, Director at CHW Small Business Accountants in Bolton highlights some common triggers which may to lead to an HMRC tax investigation, and gives some advice about how you can reduce your likelihood of being subject to one.


Read more >

15 November 2018

Ask the experts – We answer your questions on...

by

The first phase of the Making Tax Digital (MTD) initiative is drawing closer. It’s less than a year until UK businesses that are VAT registered and…


Read more >

YOUR CHALLENGES

No matter what your challenge is, we’ve probably dealt with it before.



Need an Accountant?

Get in touch >


Need an Accountant?

Get in touch >


Tax issues?

Find out more >


Tax issues?

Find out more >


Trying to grow your business?

We can help >


Trying to grow your business?

We can help >


Managing cashflow?

We can help >


Managing cashflow?

We can help >


Starting a business?

We can help >


Starting a business?

We can help >


Looking for funding?

Need help with funding? >


Looking for funding?

Need help with funding? >


Buying or selling a business?

We can help >


Buying or selling a business?

We can help >


Adopt the cloud?

We can help >


Adopt the cloud?

We can help >


What else can we do for you?

We can help >


What else can we do for you?

We can help >
CONTACT US

Get in touch, no hard sell, just a brew, a biscuit and a chat.